Skip to content

[FEATURE] LLM A/B Testing Framework — Systematic prompt and model comparison #472

Description

@gelluisaac

Description

Build a robust A/B testing framework for comparing prompts, models, and parameters
to systematically improve LLM performance.

Scope

Create statistical experimentation platform for LLM optimization.

Files to Touch/Create

  • astroml/llm/experimentation/__init__.py
  • astroml/llm/experimentation/ab_test.py — A/B test runner
  • astroml/llm/experimentation/analyzer.py — Statistical analysis
  • astroml/llm/experimentation/assigner.py — Traffic assignment
  • astroml/llm/experimentation/reporter.py — Results reporting
  • astroml/llm/experimentation/guardrails.py — Safety checks
  • api/routers/experiments.py — Experiment API
  • web/src/components/ExperimentDashboard.tsx — Dashboard UI

Experiment Types

  1. Prompt Variants: Test different prompt phrasings
  2. Model Comparison: GPT-4 vs Claude vs Llama
  3. Parameter Tuning: Temperature, top_p, max_tokens
  4. System Prompt: Different system instructions
  5. Context Strategies: Different RAG approaches

Implementation Details

  • Traffic splitting: 50/50, 90/10, etc.
  • Minimum sample size calculation
  • Statistical significance testing (t-test, chi-square)
  • Confidence intervals
  • Winner declaration automation
  • Automatic rollback on regression

Acceptance Criteria

  • Experiments run with proper randomization
  • Statistical significance calculated correctly
  • Results reproducible
  • Winner deployed automatically when significant
  • Safety metrics monitored during experiments
  • Historical experiment data retained

Metrics Tracked

  • Primary: task success rate, user satisfaction
  • Secondary: latency, cost, token usage
  • Safety: hallucination rate, toxicity

Labels

enhancement, llm, "experimentation", "optimization"

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

Type

No type

Projects

No projects

Milestone

No milestone

Relationships

None yet

Development

No branches or pull requests

Issue actions